Best Practices for Running a Successful Matching Campaign

Things you should know before you launch a matching campaign.
 

Donation matching is a powerful fundraising strategy, but its success depends on more than just offering a match. Nonprofits must take a thoughtful, strategic approach that combines clear communication, donor engagement, and the right tools. Whether you’re working with corporate partners, foundations, or everyday donors, these best practices will help you maximize the impact of your matching campaigns and build lasting donor relationships.
 

This guide covers:

• Key steps for running a successful donation matching campaign

• Practical tips for engaging donors and matchers

• Tools and strategies to streamline and measure success

 

Steps for Success

Learn how to strategically plan, promote, and execute your matching campaign to achieve maximum impact and donor engagement.
 

1. Plan Ahead: Align Campaigns with Key Fundraising Events
 

• Choose the Right Timing

  • Align matching campaigns with high-visibility fundraising events like GivingTuesday, year-end appeals, or cause-specific awareness months.
    ​

• Set Clear Goals

  • Define specific objectives, such as total funds raised or new donor acquisition, to guide your strategy.
     

• Secure Matching Partners Early

  • Reach out to corporate sponsors, foundations, or major donors well in advance to secure their participation.
     

Example: Research shows that aligning matches with year-end giving campaigns can drive higher participation, as donors are already in a philanthropic mindset (360MatchPro).

 

2. Promote Widely: Use Multi-Channel Outreach
 

• Email Campaigns

  • Send targeted emails with compelling subject lines like “Double Your Impact Today!” Include clear calls to action and personalized messages.
     

• Social Media

  • Share updates across platforms, using visuals like countdown timers and progress bars to build excitement.
     

• In-Person Events

  • Announce matches during live fundraising events to create urgency and encourage immediate participation.
     

• Leverage Storytelling

  • Highlight real-life examples of how matching has amplified impact in the past. For instance:

    • “Last year, your matched donations helped us build five new classrooms.”
       

Pro Tip: Incorporate the psychological principles of urgency and social proof by showcasing limited-time offers and sharing donor participation metrics (HBS Study).

 

3. Streamline the Process: Use Donation Matching Tools
 

• Simplify Administration

  • Platforms like MatchNice, Double the Donation or 360MatchPro help automate matching gift submissions, ensuring that both nonprofits and donors save time.
     

• Integrate Matching on Donation Pages

  • Make it easy for donors to check if their employer offers matching gifts and submit requests directly.
     

• Provide Clear Instructions

  • Include step-by-step guides for donors on how to participate in the matching process, whether it’s through their employer or a foundation.
     

Example: Nonprofits using integrated tools report a 50% increase in matching gift revenue due to streamlined processes (Double the Donation).

 

4. Track Results: Use Analytics to Evaluate and Improve
 

• Monitor Progress in Real-Time

  • Use dashboards to track how close you are to meeting your match goals.
     

• Measure Donor Behavior

  • Analyze data on donor participation rates, average gift size, and campaign ROI to understand what worked and what didn’t.
     

• Adjust Strategies

  • Use insights to refine future campaigns, such as experimenting with higher match ratios or testing different communication channels.
     

Key Metric: Nonprofits that track and adjust campaigns based on analytics report a 25% improvement in donor engagement year-over-year (Nonprofit PRO).
 

​

Best Practices for Donor Engagement

Inspire donors to take action and participate in your matching campaign with personalized approaches, urgency-driven messaging, and thoughtful recognition.

 

1. Personalize Your Approach

• Address donors by name and reference their past giving history.

• Offer custom match opportunities, such as letting donors pledge matches for specific programs or goals.
   

Example: “Thank you, Alex, for supporting our literacy program last year. This year, your donation will be doubled to help twice as many students!”

 

2. Create a Sense of Urgency

• Use time-sensitive language to encourage immediate action, such as “Donate by midnight to double your impact.”

• Incorporate countdown timers on your website and in emails.

 

3. Recognize and Celebrate Donors

• Publicly acknowledge matchers and participants on social media, newsletters, or event programs.

• Send personalized thank-you messages detailing the impact of their contributions.Example: “Thanks to your match, Sarah, we raised $20,000 to fund clean water initiatives in 10 villages!”

 

Common Challenges and How to Overcome Them

Address common barriers to donation matching, from lack of awareness to submission process complexities, with actionable solutions.
 

1. Low Awareness of Matching Opportunities

   • Educate your donors through FAQs, videos, and webinars explaining how donation matching works.
      

2. Complicated Submission Processes

   • Simplify submission by integrating platforms like MatchNice that guide donors through the process in just a few clicks.
      

3. Limited Donor Participation

   • Solution: Experiment with smaller, more frequent matches to encourage broader engagement.

​
 

Actionable Steps for Nonprofits

Implement these proven strategies to secure matching partners, engage donors effectively, and continually improve your campaigns through data insights.
 

1. Secure Matching Partners

   • Approach corporations, foundations, and major donors with a clear value proposition for their participation.
      

2. Communicate Clearly

   • Use concise messaging and engaging visuals to ensure donors understand how their contributions will be matched.
      

3. Leverage Data for Improvement

   • Regularly analyze campaign performance to identify areas for growth and optimization.

​
 

Conclusion

Running a successful donation matching campaign is both an art and a science. By combining thoughtful planning, multi-channel promotion, and donor-centric engagement strategies, nonprofits can unlock the full potential of matching campaigns. With the right tools and insights, your nonprofit can inspire greater generosity, strengthen donor relationships, and make a lasting impact.

​
 

Explore More

Dive deeper into donation matching strategies with these comprehensive guides. Each resource provides actionable insights to amplify your nonprofit's impact.
:

1. The Ultimate Guide to Donation Matching for Nonprofits
   Your one executive summary and starting point for all things donation matching.
    

2. The Power of Corporate Matching Gift Programs
   A comprehensive look at corporate philanthropy and employee gift matching.
    

3. The Psychology Behind Matching Donations
   Why It Works: Discover the behavioral science driving the success of matching campaigns.
    

4. Maximizing Foundation and Major Donor Matches
   Practical tips to secure high-value matches from major donors and foundations.
    

5. Leveraging Everyday Donors for Matching Campaigns
   Learn how to empower individual donors to become matchers